- The GOAT conversation would be totally different without championships involved
- There have been many superstar players in NBA history who did not win rings
- Number of championships won is the most important category when comparing players
The discussion surrounding the greatest NBA players of all time often revolves around their championship rings as a primary measure of their legacy. However, what if we were to reimagine the evaluation criteria and strip away the significance of championship rings? In a league that thrives on individual talent, athleticism, and unparalleled skill, determining greatness solely by the number of titles can sometimes overshadow the remarkable contributions of players who never hoisted the coveted Larry O’Brien Trophy.
This alternative perspective invites us to explore the careers and impacts of players who, despite their ring count, undeniably left an indelible mark on the game of basketball. By focusing on attributes like skill mastery, influence on the game’s evolution, statistical dominance, and sheer charisma, we embark on a journey to uncover the 10 greatest NBA players of all time if championship rings had no bearing on the conversation.
In this article, we delve into the careers of these exceptional athletes who would shine just as brightly, even in the absence of jewelry-laden accolades. By focusing on purely regular-season accolades, skill set, and raw impact of players without rings considered, here are the 10 greatest NBA players of all time if rings had zero value on legacies.
Honorable Mention
Kevin Durant
Career Statistics: 27.0 PPG, 7.1 RPG, 4.2 APG, 1.1 SPG, 1.1 BPG
Kevin Durant is a one-of-a-kind star because of his inhuman scoring ability. Even when he stands close to 7 feet tall, Durant never feels the need to force the issue on the court and still averages a career 27.3 points per game on 49.9% shooting from the field, 38.5% from three, and 88.6% from the free-throw line. A superstar forward, Durant is simply an elite offensive player who would awe everybody even more if rings weren’t taken into consideration.
Without rings on the resume, Durant’s skills would be highlighted even more when comparing him to other all-time great players. The former No. 2 overall pick can be regarded on top ahead of everyone else when it comes to pure perimeter scoring skills because he has no weakness in his handles, shooting, shot-creation, or ability to attack the rim. Due to this fact, Durant is just outside the top-10 list when in reality, he isn’t close because of his lack of championship success without the Golden State Warriors dynasty beside him.
10. Jerry West
Career Statistics: 27.0 PPG, 5.8 RPG, 6.7 APG, 2.6 SPG, 0.7 BPG
Jerry West’s legacy was the most impacted by the number of championships won. Specifically, West’s Finals record was the reason many do not place him in the absolute elite of NBA history despite being the NBA’s logo. West went 1-8 in the NBA Finals and the losses that piled up have forever changed the way the media and NBA fans regard the Lakers legend.
However, without championships taken into consideration, West would easily be a top-10 player ever. Look at his resume and how he carried the Lakers throughout the 1960s. Jerry West made 14 All-Star appearances in 14 seasons, made 12 All-NBA Teams, 5 All-Defensive Teams, and led the NBA in scoring and assists once each. Not to mention, in terms of pure skills, West was beyond special.
He was an elite playmaker, averaging 6.7 assists per game over his career, and was known to raise the play of the stars around him. Of course, his scoring was greatly respected because he averaged under 20 points per game once and that came in his rookie campaign. His highest-scoring seasons were 31.3 points, 31.2 points, 31.0 points, and 30.8 points with the Lakers.
His consistency as an offensive scorer and defensive stopper was elite and he never really slowed down until his retirement. Whether it came to shooting (West was one of the best ever), playing defense, or playmaking, the Lakers legend was one of the most skilled ever and not taking into account his 1-8 Finals record would have boosted his legacy further than ever.
9. Hakeem Olajuwon
Career Statistics: 21.8 PPG, 11.1 RPG, 2.5 APG, 1.7 SPG, 3.1 BPG
In terms of pure skill and two-way dominance, Hakeem Olajuwon is easily a top-10 player ever without championships taken into consideration. The two rings he won with the Houston Rockets are actually a testament to his greatness because he never had other elite All-Stars beside him until an older Clyde Drexler came along in 1995.
Had Olajuwon won more rings or played with a team that was able to surround him with other stars like superstars in the modern game, his legacy as an all-time great would have been even greater. Regardless, without rings taken into consideration, Olajuwon managed to win a league MVP award and won the Defensive Player of the Year award twice. There might not be a more respected defender than Hakeem.
A three-time blocks champion, two-time rebounds champion, and 9-time All-Defensive Team member, Olajuwon was a defensive stalwart and even managed to lead all players in career blocks. His defense was elite and it is even more magnified when acknowledging the iconic “Dream Shake” and post moves he employed.
Olajuwon was unstoppable in the paint for years, and until today, superstar players scramble to learn from him how to score against defenders. Hakeem was truly a complete player and as a man who could lead a franchise year after year, he would be a top-10 player ever without a doubt if championships weren’t taken into consideration.
8. Larry Bird
Career Statistics: 24.3 PPG, 10.0 RPG, 6.3 APG, 1.7 SPG, 0.8 BPG
When thinking about the iconic Boston Celtics franchise, Larry Bird’s name comes up more than anyone else. Bill Russell won 11 championships, but when not taking them into account, there would be no way anyone would be placed ahead of Larry Bird in Celtics lore.
Alongside Magic Johnson, Bird was critical to the NBA’s growing popularity during the 1980s and changed the way basketball was followed around the world. Whether it was shooting, trash-talking, or performing in critical moments, Larry Legend did it all at the highest level. For his efforts, Bird won three MVP awards as a member of the Celtics.
There might have not been a more iconic player in his time than Bird as he captivated audiences with his lack of athleticism but was able to rebound, pass, and score at an elite level. Even without championships considered, Bird was able to achieve greatness with the Celtics year after year. Had his back not acted up later in his career, Larry Legend would have had an even better career.
With 12 All-Star appearances, 10 All-NBA Team selections, three All-Defensive Team selections, and the Rookie of the Year trophy, Bird was a superstar as soon as he entered the NBA and left with a name that transcends the sport. Without his three titles included, Bird would still be a top-10 player of all time.
7. Magic Johnson
Career Statistics: 19.5 PPG, 7.2 RPG, 11.2 APG, 1.9 SPG, 0.4 BPG
Magic Johnson was a transcendent player during his time and even changed the game afterward. His unique ability to play multiple positions, especially as a 6’9″ point guard, revolutionized basketball. His exceptional court vision, passing accuracy, and unselfish playmaking changed the way the game was played.
The legendary Lakers star captured three NBA MVP awards, a testament to his consistent dominance and influence on the game. His 12 All-Star selections highlight his sustained excellence and recognition among peers, coaches, and fans.
Magic’s leadership was a cornerstone of his legacy. His charismatic presence and knack for making his teammates better contributed to his team’s success. He orchestrated the fast-paced “Showtime” era of the Los Angeles Lakers, where his passing and basketball IQ led to numerous fast-break opportunities and highlight-reel plays.
Off the court, Magic’s impact extended to the league’s popularity and globalization. His rivalry with Larry Bird helped revitalize the NBA during a crucial period and drew attention to the sport. Magic’s influence transcended basketball, and his business ventures and philanthropic efforts further demonstrated his significance beyond the court.
No doubt, Magic’s appearance in the NBA Finals as a rookie changed his legacy because starting at center in place of Kareem Abdul-Jabbar on the biggest stage greatly boosted his legacy to tremendous heights. However, even without championships considered, Magic would be a top-10 player ever because of the way he changed the game as the NBA’s first “big” point guard.
6. Kobe Bryant
Career Statistics: 25.0 PPG, 5.2 RPG, 4.7 APG, 1.4 SPG, 0.5 BPG
If the focus shifted away from championships, Kobe Bryant’s legacy would rest on his incredible skill, work ethic, versatility, and an impressive array of regular-season accolades. Renowned for his “Mamba Mentality,” Bryant’s impact on the game transcends his championship count.
Kobe’s offensive repertoire was unparalleled. His scoring prowess, footwork, and shooting proficiency allowed him to excel from anywhere on the court. His career-high 81-point game stands as a testament to his scoring ability along with two scoring titles. Beyond his scoring, Kobe’s playmaking skills cannot be overlooked. His growth as a passer and his ability to create scoring opportunities for teammates highlight his versatility.
Importantly, Kobe’s regular-season achievements reinforce his status. His single MVP award acknowledges his dominance over entire campaigns. His 18 All-Star selections underscore his consistency and reputation as one of the league’s premier players, recognized year after year by fans, peers, and coaches alike.
Defensively, Kobe’s tenaciousness and competitiveness set him apart. His 12 All-Defensive Team selections showcase his commitment to both ends of the court. He consistently guarded the opposing team’s best player, demonstrating his impact beyond scoring.
Kobe’s “Mamba Mentality” defined his work ethic and unwavering desire for improvement. His dedication to his craft was legendary, inspiring countless players to adopt a similar approach. His leadership, both on and off the court, was instrumental in fostering a culture of excellence and accountability within his teams.
Even in terms of bias, Bryant’s style of play was beautiful as it was iconic. Nobody had a prettier way of scoring and the way the shooting guard would create space and demoralize defenders on offense was as iconic as ever. There is no doubt that Kobe’s five championships benefitted his legacy greatly and he would be regarded less without them on his resume because critics will point out Bryant’s selfishness on the court at times.
5. Shaquille O’Neal
Career Statistics: 23.7 PPG, 10.9 RPG, 2.5 APG, 0.6 SPG, 2.3 BPG
If the significance of championships were set aside, Shaquille O’Neal’s standing in history would be supported by his dominant presence, impact on the game, and an array of regular-season accolades. Standing at 7’1″ with a blend of size, strength, and agility rarely seen in a player of his stature, Shaq redefined the center position through sheer force and versatility. His combination of post moves, powerful dunks, and soft touch near the rim made him an offensive juggernaut.
Defenses often struggled to contain him, resorting to double and triple teams, a testament to his undeniable influence. O’Neal led the league in scoring twice and even won three All-Star Game MVP trophies.
While his four NBA championships might not be a factor, but his three NBA Most Valuable Player awards highlight his consistent dominance throughout the regular season. These accolades speak to his impact on the court as an individual player. Additionally, Shaq’s 15 All-Star selections underscore his popularity and reputation as one of the league’s premier talents, consistently recognized by fans, coaches, and fellow players.
Beyond his scoring prowess, Shaq’s prowess on the boards and shot-blocking abilities solidify his impact on both ends of the court. His physicality and presence often disrupted opposing offenses and secured crucial possessions for his team.
Outside of his on-court attributes, Shaq’s larger-than-life personality and marketability resonated with fans worldwide, transcending basketball. His celebrity status helped draw attention to the NBA, contributing to its global popularity.
Considering his regular-season accolades, undeniable dominance, and cultural impact, Shaquille O’Neal would certainly make a compelling case for being a top-five player of all time, even without the consideration of championships.
4. Kareem Abdul-Jabbar
Career Statistics: 24.6 PPG, 11.2 RPG, 3.6 APG, 0.9 SPG, 2.6 BPG
If there is one play that can define why Kareem Abdul-Jabbar’s greatness wouldn’t be affected if championships didn’t matter, it is the skyhook shot. The skyhook is one of the most unstoppable and iconic moves in basketball history. His mastery of this shot allowed him to score consistently over defenders of all sizes, making him a scoring force throughout his career.
Kareem is the NBA’s second all-time leading scorer with 38,387 points and he won the scoring title twice and maintained a high level of offensive production for over two decades. His 20-year NBA career is a testament to his durability and commitment to the game. He was able to adapt his playing style over the years to remain effective even as he aged by not only scoring but impacting the defensive end as a four-time NBA blocks leader.
In terms of pure skills, Kareem’s style of play as a mobile and skilled center revolutionized the position. He set the template for modern big men with his ability to run the floor, pass, and stretch the defense with his skyhook. If that isn’t enough, Kareem won the NBA MVP award six times, along with being an influential figure in the realm of civil rights and social justice. He used his platform to address important issues, making a lasting impact beyond basketball. Even without rings, there is no denying that Kareem is a top-two center to ever play.
3. LeBron James
Career Statistics: 27.0 PPG, 7.4 RPG, 7.4 APG, 1.6 SPG, 0.7 BPG
LeBron James would still present a compelling case for being considered the greatest NBA player of all time if his four rings with the Heat, Cavaliers, and Lakers weren’t considered. His remarkable combination of size, skill, versatility, and impact on the game has solidified his place among basketball’s elite. He has the ability to impact every facet of the game—scoring, rebounding, playmaking, and defense. His triple-double performances showcase his unique ability to fill up the stat sheet.
As a forward, LeBron’s playmaking skills are unparalleled. He consistently ranks among the league leaders in assists and has often been the primary facilitator for his teams, creating scoring opportunities for his teammates. Even when he averaged 25.3 points per game in 2020, he led the NBA in assists per game (10.2).
Beyond skills, let’s also focus on winning intangibles. LeBron’s leadership on and off the court is exemplary. His high basketball IQ allows him to read the game, make quick decisions, and elevate the play of his teammates. His leadership qualities have guided his teams to success time and time again.
Most importantly, LeBron’s longevity and durability are exceptional. He has maintained a high level of play into his late 30s, a testament to his conditioning and commitment to his craft. No other player has played 20 seasons in the league at an elite level like James has.
While championships are often a key factor in the GOAT debate, LeBron James’ individual brilliance, versatility, leadership, and enduring impact on the game position him as a legitimate contender for the title, even if championships were not part of the conversation.
2. Michael Jordan
Career Statistics: 30.1 PPG, 6.2 RPG, 5.3 APG, 2.3 SPG, 0.8 BPG
Michael Jordan is widely regarded as the greatest player ever in reality, but even without his rings, the Chicago Bulls legend would be regarded as a top-2 player of all time. Jordan is widely regarded as one of the greatest scorers in basketball history, and certainly the best as a guard. His ability to score from anywhere on the court, whether it was mid-range jump shots, acrobatic layups, or clutch three-pointers, made him virtually unstoppable. He won the scoring title ten times and holds the highest career points per game average in NBA history (30.12).
In terms of two-way skills, Michael was also special. He was not only a scoring machine but also an excellent defender, playmaker, and rebounder. He often led his team in various statistical categories, showcasing his all-around impact on the game. Remember, Air Jordan won five regular-season MVP awards and captured the Defensive Player of the Year award.
Of course, his unparalleled competitiveness and desire to win set him apart because no athlete in America could compare to his killer will. Even without rings on his resume, Jordan’s impact transcended the basketball court. He became a global icon and his influence extended to popular culture, fashion, and marketing.
The “Air Jordan” brand became synonymous with excellence and style, revolutionizing athlete endorsements. Throughout his career, Jordan adapted and evolved his game. He transitioned from a high-flying dunker to a post-up player, showcasing his basketball IQ and willingness to adapt to changing circumstances.
In a scenario where championships were not the primary consideration, Michael Jordan’s combination of skill, competitiveness, impact, and legacy would undoubtedly position him as a strong contender for the title of the greatest NBA player of all time if only one player ahead of him is not considered.
1. Wilt Chamberlain
Career Statistics: 30.1 PPG, 22.9 RPG, 4.4 APG
If championships were not a factor in determining the greatest NBA player of all time, Wilt Chamberlain might have the greatest argument to stand above everyone else. While Chamberlain won two NBA championships in his career (1967 and 1972), his legacy often gets overshadowed by players with more championship rings.
If rings had no value, Wilt would be the man on top of the GOAT mountain. Chamberlain’s dominance on the court was unparalleled. He was a force to be reckoned with in every facet of the game, including scoring as he holds the record for the most points scored in a single game with an astonishing 100 points. He also averaged an incredible 30.1 points per game for his entire career, which is the second-highest ever.
There are a few more reasons why Wilt Chamberlain is the GOAT if we don’t count the rings. We will show you who the all-time leaders of 50-point, 40-point, and 30-point games are, and you will see a massive edge in Wilt’s favor.
30-Point Games
1. Michael Jordan – 562
2. LeBron James – 534
3. Wilt Chamberlain – 516
40-Point Games
1. Wilt Chamberlain – 271
2. Michael Jordan – 173
3. Kobe Bryant – 122
50-Point Games
1. Wilt Chamberlain – 118
2. Michael Jordan – 31
3. Kobe Bryant – 25
With regards to 30-point games, Wilt is in 3rd place, but for 40-point and 50-point games, those are the records that will probably never be broken. Just look at the ridiculous amount of 50-point games that Wilt Chamberlain had. It’s really mind-blowing to see that someone had 118 50-point games, and this could be the most important reason why he is the greatest player of all time if we don’t count the rings.
Wilt also led the league in rebounding for 11 seasons and holds numerous rebounding records, including the most rebounds in a single game (55) and the highest career rebounds per game average (22.9). The big man was also incredibly skilled. He possessed a wide array of offensive moves, including a soft touch around the rim and a reliable jump shot. His versatility allowed him to excel in different roles and positions on the court.
The superstar center also forced the league to make rule changes, such as widening the lane and implementing offensive goaltending rules. His impact on the game was so significant that the league had to adapt to his abilities. Even in terms of being the face of the NBA, Wilt played over 1,200 games in his career and averaged over 48 minutes per game (48.5) in the 1961-62 season, a feat that highlights his physical conditioning and endurance despite playing against other elite players in his era including Bill Russell. In terms of stats, dominance, and popularity, Wilt would be the greatest player ever if rings had no value.
