Vince Carter, Tracy McGrady, DeMar DeRozan Career Comparison (We Have A Winner)

Fadeaway World uses its most accurate formula to determine who had the greatest NBA career between Vince Carter, Tracy McGrady, and DeMar DeRozan.

12 Min Read

Credit: Fadeaway World

Vince Carter, Tracy McGrady, and DeMar DeRozan emerged as standout stars in their respective basketball eras, leaving an indelible mark on the NBA landscape. As key figures in their generational cohort, each player showcased electrifying scoring abilities, leadership prowess, and high-flying dunking skills that captivated audiences and dominated headlines throughout their careers.

In this comprehensive breakdown, we delve into the statistical nuances of their achievements, employing Fadeaway World’s meticulous formula to discern which of these basketball maestros carved out the most illustrious career among themselves. 


Best Stats

1. DeMar DeRozan – 21.0 PPG, 4.4 RPG, 4.0 APG, 1.0 SPG, 0.3 BPG (3 points)

2. Tracy McGrady – 19.6 PPG, 5.6 RPG, 4.4 APG, 1.2 SPG, 0.9 BPG (2 points)

3. Vince Carter – 16.7 PPG, 4.3 RPG, 3.1 APG, 1.0 SPG, 0.6 BPG (1 point)

DeMar DeRozan’s stat line embodies versatility and scoring prowess. With an average of 21.0 points per game, DeRozan stands as a consistent offensive threat. Beyond scoring, his contributions extend to playmaking, rebounding, and defensive presence. His well-rounded game earns him the top spot in this statistical comparison.

Tracy McGrady’s statistical profile showcases a dynamic player capable of impacting various facets of the game. A prolific scorer, McGrady’s 19.6 points per game highlight his offensive prowess. Additionally, his rebounding, playmaking, steals, and shot-blocking abilities underscore his versatility on the court, securing him a commendable second place in this comparison.

Vince Carter, known for his electrifying dunks and scoring ability, holds a respectable position in this statistical evaluation. With 16.7 points per game, Carter’s offensive impact is evident. While slightly trailing in other categories compared to his counterparts, his consistent contributions earn him a valuable point in this assessment.


Most NBA Championships

T1. Vince Carter – 0 Championships (3 points)

T1. Tracy McGrady – 0 Championships (3 points)

T1. DeMar DeRozan – 0 Championships (3 points)

In the grand narrative of their illustrious careers, Vince Carter, Tracy McGrady, and DeMar DeRozan find themselves in a unique echelon—tied in the pursuit of the coveted NBA championship. Despite their incredible contributions to their respective teams and the league, the pinnacle of team success, symbolized by an NBA title, remained elusive throughout their playing days.

Vince Carter soared to great heights with his iconic dunks and scoring prowess. However, the ultimate team achievement of hoisting the Larry O’Brien Trophy eluded him, casting a shadow over an otherwise stellar career. Tracy McGrady similarly fell short of the championship glory. DeMar DeRozan shares the same storyline of championship aspirations unfulfilled.


Most Scoring Titles

1. Tracy McGrady – 2 Scoring Titles (3 points)

T2. Vince Carter – 0 Scoring Titles (2 points)

T2. DeMar DeRozan – 0 Scoring Titles (2 points)

In the realm of putting the ball through the hoop with sheer brilliance, Tracy McGrady stands tall, having clinched the scoring title not once, but twice. McGrady’s ability to light up the scoreboard and lead the league in points per game on multiple occasions solidifies his status as an offensive juggernaut during his prime. His scoring titles serve as a testament to his unmatched skill, versatility, and ability to dominate on the offensive end.

Vince Carter and DeMar DeRozan, while not adorned with scoring titles, were no strangers to captivating audiences with their scoring exploits. Carter’s high-flying dunks and scoring versatility showcased an offensive repertoire that left an indelible mark on the game. Similarly, DeRozan’s smooth scoring, mid-range mastery, and clutch performances made him a constant threat on the offensive end.


Most All-NBA Team Selections

1. Tracy McGrady – 7 All-NBA Selections (3 points)

2. DeMar DeRozan – 3 All-NBA Selections (2 points)

3. Vince Carter – 2 All-NBA Selections (1 point)

In All-NBA Team selections, Tracy McGrady emerges as a beacon of excellence, securing a remarkable seven selections during his illustrious career. These accolades stand as a testament to McGrady’s consistent impact on the league, placing him among the elite players during his prime. His dynamic scoring, playmaking, and all-around skills garnered not just admiration but also official recognition from the league.

DeMar DeRozan follows suit with a commendable three All-NBA Team selections, showcasing his prowess and versatility on the court. DeRozan’s ability to consistently contribute on both ends of the floor, coupled with his offensive brilliance, earned him well-deserved nods from the league’s voting panels.

Vince Carter, known for his aerial acrobatics and scoring prowess, secured two All-NBA Team selections. Carter’s impact on the game, highlighted by his iconic moments and longevity, earned him a place among the league’s elite players during his prime.


Most All-Defensive Team Selections

T1. Tracy McGrady – 0 All-Defensive Team Selections (3 points)

T1. Vince Carter – 0 All-Defensive Team Selections (3 points)

T1. DeMar DeRozan – 0 All-Defensive Team Selections (3 points)

When talking about defensive accolades, Tracy McGrady, Vince Carter, and DeMar DeRozan share a unique commonality—none secured All-Defensive Team selections throughout their distinguished careers. While their impact on the offensive end and other facets of the game is undeniable, the recognition for their defensive contributions eluded them.

While these players may not boast All-Defensive Team selections, their broader influence on the game and their teams remains an integral part of their lasting legacies.


Most All-Star Selections

1. Vince Carter – 8 All-Star Selections (3 points)

2. Tracy McGrady – 7 All-Star Selections (2 points)

3. DeMar DeRozan – 6 All-Star Selections (1 point)

Vince Carter boasts an impressive eight All-Star selections. His gravity-defying dunks, scoring ability, and all-around impact on the court made him a perennial fan favorite and a fixture in the star-studded All-Star lineups.

Tracy McGrady earned seven All-Star selections during his illustrious career. McGrady’s ability to take over games and deliver memorable performances solidified his status as a regular presence among the league’s elite during the mid-2000s.

DeMar DeRozan garnered six All-Star selections so far in his career. His consistent performances and impact on the Toronto Raptors and later with the Chicago Bulls earned him the recognition of his peers, coaches, and fans during NBA All-Star festivities.


Total Win Shares

1. Tracy McGrady – 99.4 Win Shares (3 points)

2. Vince Carter – 84.4 Win Shares (2 points)

3. DeMar DeRozan – 78.6 Win Shares (1 point)

Tracy McGrady’s towering 99.4 Win Shares not only symbolize his individual brilliance but also emphasize his instrumental role in elevating his teams throughout his career. Vince Carter, with 84.4 Win Shares, showcases longevity and versatility that contributed significantly to team dynamics, blending scoring prowess with leadership. DeMar DeRozan’s 78.6 Win Shares underscore a consistent and impactful presence, particularly in his adept scoring and multifaceted contributions on the court.

While McGrady holds the highest Win Shares, each player’s numerical contribution aligns with the distinct qualities they brought to their teams. McGrady’s dynamic scoring and playmaking, Carter’s iconic dunks and adaptability, and DeRozan’s modern-day scoring prowess are all encapsulated in these figures.


PER (Player Efficiency Rating)

1. Tracy McGrady – 22.1 PER (3 points)

2. DeMar DeRozan – 19.5 PER (2 points)

3. Vince Carter – 18.4 PER (1 point)

Tracy McGrady’s leading 22.1 PER not only signifies his efficiency but also echoes the dynamic and versatile skill set that characterized his illustrious career. McGrady’s ability to contribute across various statistical categories while maintaining exceptional efficiency underscores his influence as an elite player.

In the closely contested realm of PER, DeMar DeRozan’s 19.5 and Vince Carter’s 18.4 further illuminate their effectiveness and significance on the court. Despite slight differences in their efficiency ratings, both DeRozan and Carter displayed consistent impact, with their scoring prowess and diverse contributions contributing to their teams’ success.


Who Has Had The Greatest NBA Career Out Of Vince Carter, Tracy McGrady and DeMar DeRozan?

1. Tracy McGrady – 22 points (4 Categories Won)

2. DeMar DeRozan – 17 points (1 Categorie Won)

3. Vince Carter – 16 points (1 Categorie Won)

Tracy McGrady, with a total of 22 points, emerges as the preeminent figure in this comprehensive comparison, and his impact on the game is nothing short of legendary. McGrady’s two scoring titles are a testament to his unparalleled offensive skill set, showcasing an ability to take over games with finesse and flair. Additionally, his seven All-NBA Team selections further affirm his status as one of the elite players during an era that featured some of the greatest talents in NBA history.

DeMar DeRozan secured the second position with 17 points. His well-rounded game extends far beyond scoring, as DeRozan consistently contributed in playmaking, rebounding, and defensive aspects. What sets DeRozan apart is not just his scoring prowess, but his ability to evolve as a player, adapting his game to fit the needs of his team. His six All-Star selections reflect not only individual excellence but also his impact on the success of his teams. DeRozan’s journey from a young talent with the Toronto Raptors to a seasoned veteran leading the Chicago Bulls is a testament to his dedication to the craft and his enduring impact on the contemporary NBA landscape.

Vince Carter occupies a unique place in NBA history with his iconic dunks and offensive brilliance. Beyond the numbers, Carter’s impact resonates in the longevity with which he graced the hardwood. Carter’s influence is not confined to statistics; it spans generations, as he played in four different decades, showcasing an enduring passion for the game. While he may not have captured an NBA championship, his impact goes beyond the pursuit of titles, defining an era of basketball that was shaped by his unparalleled athleticism and scoring prowess.

Newsletter

Stay up to date with our newsletter on the latest news, trends, ranking lists, and evergreen articles

Follow on Google News

Thank you for being a valued reader of Fadeaway World. If you liked this article, please consider following us on Google News. We appreciate your support.

Share This Article
Follow:
Francisco Leiva is a staff writer for Fadeaway World from Buenos Aires, Argentina. He is a recent graduate of the University of Buenos Aires and in 2023 joined the Fadeaway World team. Previously a writer for Basquetplus, Fran has dedicated years to covering Argentina's local basketball leagues and the larger South American basketball scene, focusing on international tournaments.Fran's deep connection to basketball began in the early 2000s, inspired by the prowess of the San Antonio Spurs' big three: Tim Duncan, Tony Parker, and fellow Argentinian, Manu Ginóbili. His years spent obsessing over the Spurs have led to deep insights that make his articles stand out amongst others in the industry. Fran has a profound respect for the Spurs' fanbase, praising their class and patience, especially during tougher times for the team. He finds them less toxic compared to other fanbases of great franchises like the Warriors or Lakers, who can be quite annoying on social media.An avid fan of Luka Doncic since his debut with Real Madrid, Fran dreams of interviewing the star player. He believes Luka has the potential to become the greatest of all time (GOAT) with the right supporting cast. Fran's experience and drive to provide detailed reporting give Fadeaway World a unique perspective, offering expert knowledge and regional insights to our content.
Leave a Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *