Bleacher Report’s Zach Buckley has proposed a trade idea that’s as bold as it is bewildering, a three-team mega-deal sending Giannis Antetokounmpo to the Golden State Warriors, Jimmy Butler to the Detroit Pistons, and a massive haul of players and picks to the Milwaukee Bucks. On paper, it’s the kind of move that would shake the entire league. In practice, though, it raises a lot of questions about logic, fit, and motivation.
Golden State Warriors Receive: Giannis Antetokounmpo (via Bucks)
Detroit Pistons Receive: Jimmy Butler (via Warriors), 2030 Golden State Warriors second-round pick
Milwaukee Bucks Receive: Jaden Ivey (via Pistons), Brandin Podziemski (via Warriors), Isaiah Stewart (via Pistons), Tobias Harris (via Pistons), 2026 Golden State Warriors first-round pick, 2027 Golden State Warriors first-round pick swap, 2028 Golden State Warriors first-round pick, 2031 Golden State Warriors first-round pick swap, 2032 Golden State Warriors first-round pick
On paper, the trade has a bit of everything: star power, young talent, and draft capital. But once you dig in, the reasoning behind it starts to crumble.
Â
The Warriors Can Get A Future After Stephen Curry
This part at least makes some sense. If the Warriors could somehow pair Giannis Antetokounmpo with Stephen Curry, they’d immediately become championship favorites again. Even as Curry nears 37, adding Giannis would give Golden State both short-term dominance and long-term security. Giannis’ defensive versatility and interior dominance would be a dream in Steve Kerr’s switch-heavy system, and offensively, the combination of Curry’s gravity and Giannis’ downhill power would be borderline unstoppable.
But the issue is chemistry. Golden State has spent years rebuilding its identity after Kevin Durant’s departure. Trading away core contributors like Jimmy Butler and Brandin Podziemski, one of their most promising young players, could fracture the balance they’ve worked to restore. Moreover, the Warriors’ future picks would all be in the hands of another team, a huge risk for a roster built around aging veterans.
Â
The Pistons Will Stand To Lose Their Youth For An Aging Star
This is where the trade idea completely falls apart. Why on earth would the Detroit Pistons, a rebuilding team built around Cade Cunningham, trade their youth for a 36-year-old Jimmy Butler? Butler is a proven winner, but his style and timeline don’t align at all with Detroit’s developmental curve.
Buckley’s logic is that Butler could bring leadership and competitiveness to a young locker room, but realistically, he’d only stunt their growth. The Pistons would also lose Ivey and Stewart, two of their most promising young pieces, for a short-term rental of a declining star.
Â
The Bucks Get Solid Talent And Future Picks In This Deal
If the Milwaukee Bucks ever get to a point where Giannis demands a trade, this package isn’t the worst possible return. They’d receive a solid young foundation in Ivey, Podziemski, and Stewart, plus five future draft assets. Tobias Harris would be included for salary matching and could be flipped later.
Still, it’s hard to imagine the Bucks parting with Giannis unless he outright forces their hand, and even then, they’d likely get better offers from younger, asset-rich teams like Oklahoma City, San Antonio, or Toronto.
Â
This Deal Defies Logic
Buckley’s trade makes for entertaining discussion, but it collapses under real-world scrutiny. The Warriors’ chemistry would be gutted, the Bucks would only consider this in a worst-case scenario, and the Pistons, arguably the biggest loser in the deal, would have no reason to mortgage their future for an aging star.
Yes, the idea of Giannis in Golden State is exciting. But this particular version? It’s one of those ‘fun for the trade machine, disastrous in real life’ scenarios.
