Newsletter
Fadeaway World
  • Fadeaway World
  • NBA News & Analysis
  • NBA Trade Rumors
  • NBA News & Media
  • Exclusive Interviews
  • NBA 2K
Reading: The All-Time NBA ‘What-If’ Team
Fadeaway WorldFadeaway World
Search
  • Fadeaway World
  • NBA News & Analysis
  • NBA Trade Rumors
  • NBA News & Media
  • Exclusive Interviews
  • NBA 2K
Follow US
Home > NBA News & Analysis > The All-Time NBA ‘What-If’ Team

The All-Time NBA ‘What-If’ Team

Eddie Bitar
Aug 23, 2019
10 Min Read
Share

We have seen so many great players in NBA history whose careers were cut short due to injuries. Often, these injuries were severe enough that these players were not able to recover from their All-NBA form, or were even forced into early retirement.

Contents
  • Point Guard: Derrick Rose
  • Shooting Guard: Tracy McGrady
  • Small Forward: Grant Hill
  • Power Forward: Bill Walton
  • Center: Yao Ming
  • 6th Man: Brandon Roy

It can be particularly difficult to rank these players, as many come to mind. However, a select few stand out as the very best players whose careers could have been so much better.

To make this interesting, five players will be placed in a starting lineup per position. Each of these five guys stand out as the greatest players whose careers were unfortunately tarnished by unavoidable injuries.

Point Guard: Derrick Rose

Derrick Rose

Derrick Rose was one of the greatest physical athletes we have ever seen. He was quick, powerful, and extremely explosive. He used to drive with force to the rim, and finish over multiple defenders even at his miniature size as a point guard. Nothing could stop Rose from attacking the rim, and it earned him his MVP award in 2011. Rose was simply an unstoppable force whose injuries cut his prime very short. He was even developing a very efficient jumper to add to his arsenal which would have made Rose one of the best point guards of all-time. However, a torn ACL proved to be the end of one of the most dominating point guard primes ever.

Rose has since returned with a calmer approach to the game without much of his explosiveness. Rose can still score the ball, and can probably average 20 if he is the main scoring option. While Rose is no longer an All-Star player, he is still a good point guard who still wants to prove he has still got the MVP in him. For the time being, he is the starter as the greatest “What-If” point guard.

Shooting Guard: Tracy McGrady

150924144622-20150924-tracy-mcgrady-top-10-orlando-magic-plays.1280x720

McGrady was an absolute scoring machine. He was so dominant, that many even began to rank him as the best player in the league- ahead of a then-prime Kobe Bryant. At the very least, he was considered the most unstoppable player when he was in Orlando playing for the Magic. He never averaged less than 25 points in his four seasons playing for the Magic, and even peaked with a 32 ppg season. When he was with Orlando, T-Mac was simply unstoppable. He could hurt you from three, from the mid-range, and was an ultra-athlete when he attacked the rim. McGrady was as good a scorer as any of the greatest of all time.

He was eventually traded to the Houston Rockets, where he would join forces with Yao Ming. McGrady continued his dominant play with 4 excellent seasons with the Rockets, before injuries cut his career short. In his fifth season with the Rockets, he only managed 35 games during the regular season and became a shell of himself. He was never able to recover from a variety of back-related issues, and this derailed his career tremendously. McGrady then fell off the map, never averaging more than a mere 9 points a game as a role-player.

When he was healthy, McGrady was an offensive force who averaged over 21 points for 8 straight seasons. Besides scoring the ball with ease, T-Mac was an extremely effective playmaker who consistently averaged over 5 assists per game. He was very adept at finding open players whenever he attracted double and triple teams and had a very high basketball I.Q.

Without a question, T-Mac is one of the greatest players who could have been even greater.

Small Forward: Grant Hill

Grant-Hill-ppcorn pistons

If we are to mention a single player whose career was the most damaged, it has to be Grant Hill. Grant Hill was supposed to be Michael Jordan. Hill was the next great player who was supposed to dominate and become the face of the league much like MJ did. Hill was completely unstoppable. He had it all offensively and was a near-perfect athlete.

Hill was unstoppable driving to the rim, thanks to a mix of sublime handles and quick first step. Hill used to beat any defender with cross-over dribble moves and attack the basket with force. He would dunk all over defenders, and finish with a soft touch whenever he decided to play it safe. Hill was also very proficient from mid-range and could dish out to teammates with ease. Grant Hill was almost a perfect small forward, with a perfect package that resembles LeBron James. Hill should have been one of the greatest of all-time, but a left leg injury cut his career way too short.

Power Forward: Bill Walton

BillWalton

Bill Walton is a Hall-of-Famer who is recognized as a very accomplished big man. Yet, Walton could have been even greater. Walton was a dominating big who could score around the basket and crash the glass for large amounts of rebounds. He also became one of the most outspoken players in NBA history, thanks to his charisma and competitive attitude.

Walton was one of the most ultimate players who could help win you games, thanks to his towering height and splendid intangibles. Unfortunately, his feet would not hold up preventing him from achieving even more injuries. He was simply a very large man, and his style of play did not allow his feet to hold him up at a high level for too long. Walton was constantly forced to play through pain, which often derailed his production.

Walton was still a very accomplished player, winning two NBA titles, a Finals MVP award, and a regular season MVP award. Walton could have been even greater, perhaps recognized alongside Kareem, Wilt, Russel, and Shaq as an all-time great.

Center: Yao Ming

Yao-Ming

Yao Ming changed the NBA. He was the first player to make such a revolutionary impact in the Chinese market, with millions of fans watching his games and supporting him throughout his career. Perhaps we will not find another player with an international impact like that of Yao Ming.

Besides his off-the-court impact, Yao Ming was a spectacular player. He stood 7’6”, and had the skills of a forward. He could shoot the ball, pass, rebound, and block shots. At such a towering height, his impact could not be denied. He was a walking 20-10 player who could easily swat away 2 shots per game. Alongside T-Mac in Houston, Yao was a massive problem for opposing teams.

He constantly suffered with leg injuries throughout his career, which forced him to miss many games. Rockets fans could never really count on him, or his partner T-Mac, to keep healthy throughout the entirety of a season. This is why the Rockets never managed to win with Yao and T-Mac, as they just could not consistently stay healthy.

Yao is one of the greatest centers of all time and is the greatest “What-If” center. If Yao and T-Mac were able to stay healthy, it might have been possible for the Rockets to have another championship in their trophy cabinet.

6th Man: Brandon Roy

Photo by Jonathan Ferrey/Getty Images

Brandon Roy was an absolute beast. He could drop 20 in his sleep and was one of the most clutch players ever. Drafted out of college, Roy was already an All-Star player. He could score with the best players in the league and was a great athlete. He had a silky jumper, a knack for finishing at the rim, and excellent athletic ability and quickness. Quite simply, Roy was a perfect two-guard.

Unfortunately, Roy’s career never gained the traction it should have. He was forced into retirement after only 5 seasons, due to a horrible knee condition. Roy was on his way to becoming one of the greatest guards in NBA history, but injuries proved to be another massive disappointment. For the time being, many can only wonder what-if Roy was healthy, and where his career would have been. Roy is the greatest “What-If” 6th man in NBA history.

Next

The Game Everyone Wants To Watch: Lakers All-Time Five vs. Bulls All-Time Five

The Los Angeles Lakers All-Time Roster Is The Best In NBA History

The 10 Most Incredible NBA Finals Records

Follow on Google News

Thank you for being a valued reader of Fadeaway World. If you liked this article, please consider following us on Google News. We appreciate your support.

TAGGED:Derrick Rose
Share This Article
Facebook Email Copy Link Print
ByEddie Bitar
Eddie Bitar is a senior staff writer for Fadeaway World from Denver, Colorado. Since joining the team in 2017, Eddie has applied his academic background in economics and finance to enhance his sports journalism. Graduating with a Bachelor's degree from and later a Master's degree in Finance from Utrecht in 2018, he integrates statistical analysis into his articles. This unique approach provides readers with a deeper understanding of basketball through the lens of financial and economic concepts.Eddie's work has not only been a staple at Fadeaway World but has also been featured in prominent publications such as Sports Illustrated. His ability to break down complex data and present it in an accessible way creates an engaging and informative way to visualize both individual and team statistics. From finding the top 3 point shooters of every NBA franchise to ranking players by cost per point, Eddie is constantly finding new angles to use historical data that other NBA analysts may be overlooking.A lifelong basketball fan, Eddie grew up trying to mimic Jason Kidd's game. When asked which NBA player, past or present, he would most like to interview, Eddie's choice is clear: Jason Kidd. He admires Kidd's genius at playing point guard and his ability to lead a team to two NBA Finals appearances. Eddie believes Kidd is an underrated star who deserves more praise, and he would relish the opportunity to pick his brain and discuss the intricacies of the game.
Previous Article The 2019-20 Projected Starting Lineup For The Chicago Bulls
Next Article 4 Most Overrated NBA Players Right Now
Leave a Comment

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Newsletter

Stay up to date with our newsletter on the latest news, trends, ranking lists, and evergreen articles

Newsletter
Facebook X-twitter Instagram

You Might Also Like

Minnesota Timberwolves News & Analysis

Anthony Edwards Gets Real On Putting “Belt To A**” On Elite Players Like Kevin Durant, LeBron James, Stephen Curry

October 3, 2025
Golden State Warriors News & Analysis

Steve Kerr Took A Page From Phil Jackson’s Book To Avoid Contract Distractions During Warriors’ Season

October 3, 2025
Golden State Warriors News & Analysis

Seth Curry Admits He Didn’t Want To Team Up With Stephen Curry Until Now

October 3, 2025
Sep 29, 2025; Denver, CO, USA; Denver Nuggets player Nikola Jokic (15) takes questions during media day at Ball Arena. Mandatory Credit: Isaiah J. Downing-Imagn Images
Denver Nuggets News & Analysis

Nikola Jokic Remains Loyal To The Nuggets Despite Not Signing An Extension This Summer

October 3, 2025

NBA - Fadeaway World

  • Atlanta Hawks
  • Boston Celtics
  • Brooklyn Nets
  • Charlotte Hornets
  • Chicago Bulls
  • Cleveland Cavaliers
  • Dallas Mavericks
  • Denver Nuggets
  • Detroit Pistons
  • Golden State Warriors
  • Houston Rockets
  • Indiana Pacers
  • Los Angeles Clippers
  • Los Angeles Lakers
  • Memphis Grizzlies
  • Miami Heat
  • Milwaukee Bucks
  • Minnesota Timberwolves
  • New Orleans Pelicans
  • New York Knicks
  • Oklahoma City Thunder
  • Orlando Magic
  • Philadelphia 76ers
  • Phoenix Suns
  • Portland Trail Blazers
  • Sacramento Kings
  • San Antonio Spurs
  • Toronto Raptors
  • Utah Jazz
  • Washington Wizards

Pages

  • NBA Trade Rumors
  • NBA Media
  • Exclusive NBA Interviews
  • NBA 2K News & Updates

© 2025 Fadeaway World @ All Rights Reserved

  • About Fadeaway World
  • Fadeaway World Authors
  • Editorial Team
  • Ethics Policy
  • Corrections Policy
  • Editorial Guidelines
  • Fact-Checking Policy
  • Contact Us
Welcome Back!

Sign in to your account

Username or Email Address
Password

Lost your password?